Skip to content

Pros and Cons of Roof Coatings for Aging Flat Roofs in New Jersey

Roof coatings for aging flat roofs

If your commercial flat roof is showing signs of wear but isn’t quite ready for a full replacement, roof coatings may be the solution. Coating systems can restore waterproofing, improve energy efficiency, and extend roof life—all at a fraction of the cost of re-roofing.

But before you commit, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons of roof coatings for aging flat roofs, especially in New Jersey’s variable climate.

At Boundless Roofing & Chimney, we’ve helped hundreds of property owners decide whether roof coatings are the right choice for their buildings. Here’s what you need to know.


What Are Roof Coatings?

Roof coatings are liquid-applied membranes designed to protect, restore, and extend the lifespan of existing roofing systems. They’re most commonly used on flat or low-slope roofs that are structurally sound but weathered or leaking.

Common types of commercial roof coatings:

  • Silicone: Great for ponding water and UV resistance

  • Acrylic: Reflective and affordable, but not ideal for standing water

  • Polyurethane: High durability for foot traffic and hail resistance

  • Asphalt-based/aluminum: Used on older BUR or modified bitumen systems

Coatings are applied over EPDM, TPO, PVC, modified bitumen, metal, and more—provided the roof is properly prepped.


Pros of Roof Coatings

1. Cost-Effective Alternative to Replacement

Coating a roof can cost 40%–60% less than full tear-off and replacement, making it a smart choice for budget-conscious building owners.

Example: Instead of spending $250,000 replacing a 25,000 sq. ft. roof, coating might cost $100,000–$150,000 and add 10–15 years of life.


2. Extend Roof Life by 10–20 Years

A properly applied roof coating seals cracks, halts leaks, and protects the membrane from UV rays and thermal shock. It essentially creates a new weatherproof barrier on top of the old roof.


3. Improved Energy Efficiency

Most commercial roof coatings are white or reflective, meaning they reduce solar heat absorption. This lowers rooftop temperatures, cuts HVAC costs, and may qualify for energy rebates.

 Silicone and acrylic coatings can reflect up to 85% of sunlight, reducing indoor temperatures by up to 10°F.


4. Minimal Disruption to Building Use

Unlike roof replacement, which involves noise, debris, and downtime, roof coatings are low-impact. Tenants and operations continue without major interruptions.


5. Eco-Friendly and Sustainable

Coating extends the life of existing materials, keeping tons of roofing waste out of landfills. Many systems are low-VOC and qualify for LEED credits or cool roof designations.


6. Can Be Reapplied for Longer Lifespan

Many coating systems can be recoated every 10–15 years for continued protection—no tear-off needed—creating a renewable roof system.


 Cons of Roof Coatings

1. Not Suitable for All Roofs

Roof coatings only work if the existing roof:

  • Is structurally sound

  • Has minimal moisture infiltration

  • Has no significant membrane separation or rot

If your roof is heavily deteriorated, replacement may be the only option.


2. Requires Proper Prep and Expertise

Surface preparation is critical. Improper cleaning, substrate priming, or application can cause coating failure.

That’s why it’s essential to hire an experienced contractor like Boundless Roofing & Chimney, who will:

  • Power wash and prep the surface

  • Repair existing seams, cracks, and blisters

  • Apply base coat and top coat per manufacturer specs

  • Provide a labor and material warranty


3. Limited Cure Time and Weather Dependency

Coating must be applied during dry, mild weather—typically spring through fall. It needs several hours or days to cure, depending on the material.

 Rain, humidity, or freezing temperatures can delay or damage the application.


4. Doesn’t Solve Structural Problems

Coatings are not a fix for deck failure, collapsed insulation, or drainage issues. If your roof has sagging or serious ponding, structural repair or tapered insulation may be required first.


5. Warranty Limitations

Some coatings come with limited warranties (10–20 years) that may not match a full roof replacement’s NDL (no dollar limit) system warranties. It’s important to understand exactly what’s covered—labor, materials, or both.

Boundless Roofing & Chimney can help you compare options and select a coating with strong, certified coverage.


Is a Roof Coating Right for Your Commercial Building?

Coatings may be the right solution if:

  • Your roof is 10–20 years old, showing wear but structurally sound

  • You have isolated leaks or minor blisters, not widespread rot

  • You want to delay replacement for budget or timing reasons

  • You need to improve energy efficiency quickly

  • You’re looking for a renewable solution with minimal disruption


Get a Free Commercial Roof Coating Estimate

Before deciding between coating and replacement, schedule a free roof inspection with Boundless Roofing & Chimney. We’ll assess:

  • Roof age and material type

  • Moisture levels

  • Membrane condition

  • Drainage and slope

  • Warranty eligibility

📞 Call us today at 973-960-7921
📩 Or request your free roof coating estimate

We serve commercial property owners across New Jersey with honest assessments, certified installers, and full system warranties.


Final Verdict

Roof coatings offer a smart, sustainable, and budget-friendly option for aging commercial roofs—if applied correctly and in the right conditions. At Boundless Roofing & Chimney, we help you make informed decisions that protect your building and bottom line.

Whether you’re managing a warehouse, retail center, or multi-unit facility, roof coatings might just be the upgrade you didn’t know you needed.

Send Us A Message

Honest Pricing & Friendly, Expert Team

Get your FREE Estimate Today!

Get trusted, high-quality roofing and chimney care with Baba Roofing & Chimney. Serving all of New Jersey, we provide reliable solutions from repairs to full installations

Back To Top